The only official copy of this file is the one online at https://fsd84.bis.bnl.gov/ESR/ Date Printed: Oct 26, 2010

Experiment Safety Review Form

Review Number: PO-008-2009


PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR: Stephen Pate    
GROUP: PHENIX
EXT: 7421 E-MAIL: pate@nmsu.edu LIFE NUMBER: P5093

Project Title: PHENIX FVTX Detector Assembly Lab
Location(s): 0510
Area(s): 0510-FIRST-1-116, 0510-SECOND-2-91
Proposed Start Date and Duration: 3/1/2010 - 2 years

SIGNATURES: 
Principal Investigator: Stephen Pate Date:  
Experiment Review Coordinator:   Date:  
Local Contact: DHARMAWARDANE, KAHANAWITA (Vipuli) Date:  
Local Contact: Sean Stoll Date:  
    Date:  
    Date:  
Reviewer: Ronald Gill Date: 1/19/2010
Reviewer: J. Vignola Date:  
Reviewer: Michael Zarcone Date: 1/15/2010
Reviewer: Karl Kusche Date:  
Reviewer: Marteenio Rankine Date:  
Reviewer: F. Craner Date:  
Approval
Department Chair:
  
Date:  
Review/Approval (ERC) Comments: 10/26/2010 1:23 PM Use of Sr-90 source was added.
02/02/2010 10:39 AM This ESR was reviewed and approved by the Physics Department ESSH Committee.
Walkthrough Signature: Ronald Gill Date: 2/3/2010
Expiration Date (max 1 yr.): 2/15/2011
   
FUA Change Required?  No
Fire Rescue Run Card Changes Required?  No
Has a NEPA Review been Performed for this Project?  Don't Know
Required Approvals (i.e., IACUC, IBC, etc.): None.
   
Project Termination Acceptance Signature:
  
Comments: 
Date:  

I. Define the Scope of the Work


A. Description

The purpose of this project is to assemble the PHENIX FVTX detector in preparation for its installation in the PHENIX experiment in Building 1008. The detector uses silicon strip sensors, built by Hamamatsu, which have been placed on a substrate (with digitizing electronics) by SiDet at Fermilab. We will take these finished sensor/substrates, called "wedges", and assemble them into a detector system. Additional read-out-cards (ROCs) will be installed with the wedges in a mechanical cage; the mechanical structure and ROCs will be built elsewhere and delivered to BNL for assembly in these labs. There is an ORTEC 4-channel 1000 V low-current bias supply for use with the silicon sensors. Typical applied voltages will be around 100 V. Standard coaxial cable, with SHV and SMA connectors, will be used. The rooms will not operate as "clean rooms" but some clean room equipment will be used to limit contamination; masks for the nose and mouth, gloves, a sticky pad at the door, and an air filter for Room 2-91. None of these pose any safety hazards. Each room will have a dry box for storage of the silicon sensors. The dry box will be connected to bottles of dry air using standard pressurized air-handling equipment.  At most two bottles will reside in each room, attached to standard bottle racks. The assembly and testing will make use of standard laboratory tools (screwdrivers, wrenches, etc.) and test equipment (CAT III multimeters, oscilloscopes, computers and interface boards, etc.) which pose no hazards.

The coolant Novec 7200 (made by 3M) will be used to cool the wedges during testing. Some information from the manufacturer's description of this fluid: "Novec 7200 is nonflammable and does not exhibit flammability characteristics under normal operating and storage conditions. This fluid is highly resistant to thermal breakdown and hydrolysis in storage and during use. Recommended handling procedures are provided in the pertinent Material Safety Data Sheet. The toxicological testing completed on Novec 7200 fluid shows the overall toxicity is low. The material is minimally irritating to the eyes, non-irritating to the skin and is not a mutagen. This material is rated “practically non-toxic” through inhalation. A twenty-eight day inhalation study has helped establish a recommended exposure guideline of 200 ppm for an eight-hour average worker exposure per day." A product information sheet and MSDS for Novec 7200 are included in this ESR submission.

A water-cooled chiller will be used to cool the Novec 7200.  The water used will be discharged into the drain.  In order to minimize water used in this way, the chiller will only be used when needed and will not be left running overnight or unattended.

A sealed 330uCi  Sr-90 source (BNL ID# 200898)  will be used to test the detector modules in lab 2-91. The source is housed in a metal collimator to minimize exposure to personnel



Equipment manuals or procedures that are controlled documents:

None.



B. Human Performance Factors

The greatest source of stored energy in the lab that could hurt someone will be the pressurized bottles of dry air. Standard bottle-handling procedures will be used to prevent injury. The greatest danger to the project is damage to the silicon sensors during the assembly. The use of an air filter, the entry-way sticky pad, gloves and masks should mitigate the risk of damage. In the beginning there will need to be some learning about how to safely handle the "wedges" and we will need to develop protocols and techniques to prevent damage.



C. Waste Minimization/Pollution Prevention

This project does not routinely generate hazardous waste. Whenever new materials or processes are introduced, their impact on the waste stream is considered. Low hazard materials are used wherever possible.



D. Materials Used /Waste Generated

 
Materials UsedDisposal MethodAmount per UseAmount per YearComments
Novec 7200Fugitive3.00 ltr3.00 ltrNovec 7200 is used in a closed loop coolant system. We don't intend to "dispose" of any of it. Very small quantities might be spilled during installation and modification of the coolant system.
Arclad 7876 adhesive stripsTrash5.00 g1000.00 gThese adhesive strips are used to attach the FVTX sensors to a backplane. Very few of these will end up in the trash.
Thermal greaseTrash1.00 ml1.00 ltrThermal grease is used between the FVTX backplanes and the cooling plate. Minor amounts will need to be wiped up and discarded.

II. Identify and Analyze Hazards Associated with the Work

The following hazards were identified:

Physical Hazards:

Chemical Hazards:

Ionizing and Non-ionizing Radiation Hazards:

Biological Hazards:

Offsite Work:

Other Issues (Security, Notifications, Community, etc.):

Significant Environmental Aspects

III. Develop and Implement Hazard Controls and Assess Risk

A. Physical Hazards, Tasks and Controls
Hazard, Default Controls, Task Specific Info Risk Level
Hazard: Compressed gases (lecture bottles, cylinders, gas lines)
 Default Controls:
Engineering Controls
• Use regulators, hoses and components compatible for gas used and rated for maximum regular output, or install pressure relief device.
• Label piping/tubing if great than 10 ft, passes through walls/barriers or bundled to other lines.
• If manifolds are used, rate for 5x max. system pressure and use isolation/backflow valves leak test to maximum pressure.
Administrative Controls
• Remove regulator and install valve cap cylinder when not in use.
• Transport cylinders on approved cart; secure cylinder to a fixed object/wall.
Note: No filling of cylinders without SME approved procedure/equipment.
Training: Compressed Gas Safety (TQ-COMPGAS1)
PPE: Safety glasses when installing/removing/ or adjusting regulator
Comply with SBMS Subject Area “Compressed Gas Cylinders and Related Systems”.
Review installation for applicability to Pressure Safety Subject Area.
Negligible (0-20)
Hazard: Soldering of electronic components
 Default Controls:
Engineering Controls
• Substitute non-lead solder when applicable to components.
• Designate area (eg metal tray, or disposable liner).
• Minimum PPE: Safety glasses
 Task Specific Info:

Solder scraps are collected in a can for recycling. Wash hands after handling solder.

Negligible (0-20)
Hazard: Low-current high-voltage power supplies (Other)
 Default Controls:
 
 Task Specific Info:

All routine work with high voltage is done with grounded enclosures and approved cables and connectors.

Negligible (0-20)

B. Chemical Hazards, Tasks and Controls
None

C. Environmental Hazards, Tasks and Controls (include on/off site transportation and products/services)
Hazard, Default Controls, Task Specific Info Risk Level
Hazard: Any use of once-through cooling water with a flow of 4 gpm – 24 hrs/day (10 gpm – 8 hrs/day, daily use of >15 gpm for >60 days) and discharging to the sanitary sewer
 Default Controls:
Contact ECR to evaluate
 Task Specific Info:

The chiller will only be used when needed, and it will not be left running overnight or unattended.

Negligible (0-20)

D. Radiation Hazards, Tasks and Controls
Hazard, Default Controls, Task Specific Info Risk Level
Hazard: Sealed radioactive sources (SRS) –not accountable
 Default Controls:
bring up accountable table in Subject Area)
Contact FS Rep to discuss specific controls which may include:
Engineering Controls:
• Physical areas boundary
• Shielding
• Inventoried sources must be stored securely (locked) when not in use.

Administrative Controls:
• Inventory checks and leak tests
• Registration and source Id labels.
• Updates to Department and Master Custodians, using SRS Data Forms.
• Rad Area Postings, and Rad Material labelling
• Radiological Work Permit.
• All radioactive materials brought on-site or taken off-site must go through I&SM.

Training:
• Rad Worker I (HP-RWT-002), or GERT.

Dosimeter/Monitoring:
• TLD, ring dosimetry
• RCT monitoring/job coverage
 Task Specific Info:

The  FS Rep will be consulted to discuss specific controls which may include: shielding,  radiological postings,  locked storage of source when not in use, required training and dosimetry.

The source cannot be removed from its collimator, nor can the size of the apertures be modified, without further experiment safety and ALARA reviews.  Sealed radioactive sources are used only in properly marked controlled areas.

Practice ALARA principles to minimize rad exposure through the use of shielding and distance and by minimizing time of exposure.

Negligible (0-20)

E. Biological Hazards, Tasks and Controls
None

F. Offsite Work Hazards, Tasks and Controls
None

G. Other Issues (Security, Notifications to Other Organizations, Community Involvement, etc.)
None

H. Recommended Exposure Monitoring

Description or comments: 

I. EPHA Determination

 
Chemical NameQuantity (lbs, gal)Location (Bldg/Room#)

IV. Perform Work Within Controls

A. Recommended Training and Medical Surveillance Summary

B. Personnel Training, Qualification, and Authorization List

Employee/Guest Name Life/Guest# Required Training Course(s) Signed
Stephen PateP5093Compressed Gas Safety (TQ-COMPGAS1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Hazard Communication (HP-IND-200) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Radiological Worker I (TQ-RW1-PART1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
2/2/2010 10:11:09 AM
Vipuli DharmawardaneE7101Radiological Worker I (TQ-RW1-PART1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Hazard Communication (HP-IND-200) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Compressed Gas Safety (TQ-COMPGAS1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
 
Hussein Al-Ta'aniE6544Compressed Gas Safety (TQ-COMPGAS1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Hazard Communication (HP-IND-200) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Radiological Worker I (TQ-RW1-PART1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
 
Elaine TennantE9049Radiological Worker I (TQ-RW1-PART1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Hazard Communication (HP-IND-200) [ UNASSIGNED ]
Compressed Gas Safety (TQ-COMPGAS1) [ UNASSIGNED ]
 
S. Stoll19796  

C. Emergency Procedures
None

D. Transportation
None

E. Notifications
None

F. Termination/Decommissioning

When the project is completed, the equipment will be released for other uses and the rooms returned to the Department in acceptable condition.

V. Provide Feedback

None

VI. Attachments



Attached Files:

Novec7200MSDS.pdf